The Robustness of Pi & Pid Controllers in the Presence of Sampling Jitter
نویسندگان
چکیده
Variations in sampling time, or sampling jitter, is a common industrial control problem. This paper investigates the performance of industrial PI and PID controllers in the presence of sampling jitter. The commonly employed controller performance assessment (CPA) benchmark index is used on a wide variety of industrial plant models to show that while the PI control is relatively immune to jitter, the derivative component of the PID controller causes the PID controller to exhibit excessive sensitivity to sampling jitter, although this can be partially compensated by appropriate filtering.
منابع مشابه
A Thorough Comparative Analysis of PI and Sliding Mode Controllers in Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor Drive Based on Optimization Algorithms
In this paper, the speed tracking for permanent magnet synchronous motor (PMSM) in field oriented control (FOC) method is investigated using linear proportional-integral (PI) controller, sliding mode controller (SMC) and its advanced counterparts. The advanced SMCs considered in this paper are fuzzy SMC (FSMC) and sliding mode controller with time-varying switching gain (SMC+TG) which can effec...
متن کاملGenetic Feedforward-Feedback Controller for Functional Electrical Stimulation Control of Elbow Joint Angle
Background: Functional electrical stimulation (FES) is the most commonly used system for restoring functions after spinal cord injury (SCI). Objective: In this study we investigated feedback PID and feedforward-feedback P-PID controllers for regulating the elbow joint angle. Methods: The controllers were tuned based on a nonlinear muculoskeletal model containing two links, one joint with one de...
متن کاملComparison Between Robust PID and Predictive PI Controllers with Constrained Control Signal Noise Sensitivity
A performance comparison between PID and predictive PI (PPI) controllers, i.e., two different prediction methods, is presented. Optimization of controller and measurement filter parameters, considering load disturbance rejection, robustness and noise sensitivity, is performed for a batch of industrially representative processes. For a majority of the processes and the constraints chosen, result...
متن کاملRandom delay effect minimization on a hardware-in-the-loop networked control system using optimal fractional order PI controllers
Random delays have serious effects in networked control systems, which deteriorate the performance and may even cause instability of the system. Hence a controller which can make the plant stable at large values of delay is always desirable in NCS systems. Our previous work on OFOPI controller showed that fractional order PI controllers have larger jitter margin (maximum value of delay for whic...
متن کاملFragility-Rings - A Graphic Tool for PI/PID Controllers Robustness-Fragility Analysis
The aim of the paper is to present the Delta 20 Fragility-Rings plot and its use for robustness-fragility analysis of proportional integral (PI) and proportional integral derivative (PID) controllers. Using the Delta 20 Fragility Index and the Nyquist plot it shows the areas on the L(jω) plane corresponding to robustness-fragile, robustness-non-fragile and robustnessresilient controllers provid...
متن کامل